 |
|
Transparent PowerIsolator 4 By Ed Masterson April 2003 
I have long dreamed of having a custom A/V room, designed from the ground up in order to obtain optimum performance from my audio/video system. The design would address everything from room acoustics to EMI noise isolation. When it comes to AC power, if cost was no object, I would have separate dedicated transformers on the power pole for each electronic component. Although totally impractical, this would be the best way to keep noise generated by other electronic devices, such as computers, water heaters, refrigerators and even other audio components, from infiltrating my beloved sound system. A more practical approach would be to use power filters like the new Transparent PowerIsolator 4, which provides both noise filtering and surge protection. On the surface, this may not sound so impressive, since you can purchase a device at your local hardware store that does this for around three dollars. However, filtering power from the AC lines without negative effects on sound or picture quality is extraordinarily tricky and rarely accomplished without sonic downsides. The PowerIsolator 4 measures eighteen-and-seven-eighths inches wide, five-and-one-eighth inches tall and nine inches deep, weighs 17 pounds, and sells for $1,895. The front panel has the Transparent nameplate and a single LED that lights up only when there is a problem. The unit is designed to be rack-mountable or to sit on an equipment shelf. The enclosure has a black anodized machined aluminum faceplate and a black powder-coated steel shell. The unit feels solid and looks well built. It has four hubell hospital grade 5-15 outlets for up to four different components. Transparent recommends one PI 4 for each component for optimum performance. However, other configurations, such as one unit for analog components and one for digital components, are said to achieve very good performance. The Technology The obvious goal of a power filter is to remove noise from the power line in hopes of lowering the noise floor in a piece of electronics. Most filter devices on the market use inline chokes or capacitors, which create a phase shift between the voltage and current. This can cause the current to lead or lag the voltage. According to Transparent, this causes a small drop in power supply performance, which can be heard as added harshness in some cases, or a dull lifeless sound in others. Power correction is not a new idea, as there are many different products, each with different design philosophies. Another popular approach for improved power is power regeneration. This approach uses a circuit to convert the AC power to DC and back to AC again. This is like adding an amplifier to drive your amplifier. This is not what Transparent does to clean up your power. The PI 4 design uses no components in the power path in order to avoid any possibility of limiting the current. The noise filter is designed to filter everything from 1 KHz and above, with the minus three dB point at 2 KHz. The all-passive filter in the PI 4 is designed specifically to avoid any phase shift at 60 Hz. Transparent claims that this is key to providing noise filtering with no negative effects. When it comes to surge protection, it’s pretty easy to understand the importance of protecting your investments, yet once again, providing surge protection without affecting sound or picture quality can be difficult. To top that off, most surge suppressors use MOVs that cannot react fast enough to protect the upstream equipment from damage in the most extreme cases. The PI 4 employs a hybrid circuit, which utilizes avalanche diodes. Avalanche diodes represent state of the art performance and cost in surge protection. These devices react in picoseconds where as MOVs react in nanoseconds. The PI 4’s surge protection circuit does not allow any voltage above 200 volts to pass into the connected equipment and theoretically can protect against extreme cases, such as lightning strike voltage surges. Transparent backs up this claim with a five-year connected equipment warranty. Movies/Music 
Set-up is as simple as plugging in a power cord. Initially, I connected only my Plus Piano HE -3200 to see what effect filtered power would have on my picture. I put in “Scooby-Doo” (Warner Home Video) and was amazed by the obvious changes that occurred. During the scene where Scooby and Shaggy are trapped by the monsters, I saw an obvious improvement in the colors, which all appeared brighter and better defined. In particular, the fur on Scooby looked more real. I could see variations in the brown that were not noticeable before. Additionally, I could see the shadowing around the fur and noticed subtle movements in the fur as Scooby and Shaggy discussed their impending doom. The PowerIsolator provided better edges to the images, making them look more three-dimensional.I then disconnected the projector and connected a Linn Twin amplifier and Conrad Johnson 16LS preamplifier to the PI 4. Although I have always been a little skeptical about how much difference a power filter can make, I was amazed at the improvements that I heard. During “Tom Thumb,” the third track on Bob Belden’s Shades of Blue (Blue Note), I immediately noticed the increased separation in the instruments. The bass line was more clearly defined and I could hear more of the subtleties. The cymbals had an increased presence in my room and gave me a greater sense of being present at the live performance. During track five “Siete Ocho,” I was astonished by how real the cymbals sounded. I could hear more of the inner detail as the cymbal resonated and visualize the resonance circling the cymbal as it decayed naturally into darkness. The transient attacks that occurred when the drumstick hit the rim of the drum seemed more believable than I have ever heard in my system. On Track Seven, “Hum Drum Blues,” Holly Cole’s voice floated beautifully in the center of the stage. The saxophone frankly blew me away. It appeared out of darkness almost as if it were in the room. I could hear the air as it left the horn. The subtlest sounds in the body of the instrument were naturally audible as never before and translated into a more believable presentation. “Before You Accuse Me” on Eric Clapton’s Unplugged CD (Reprise) drew me in beautifully. I have heard this disc many times and have always felt like the stage was little compressed and the highs been on the edgy side. With the PI 4, most of the maladies were gone. Eric Clapton’s voice seemed more natural than ever, with very little edginess. The stage seemed larger, with better separation between the instruments. On track Three, “Hey Hey,” I was mesmerized by the melody created by the dueling guitars. I normally skip this track, but ended up listening to it from beginning to end a couple of times. I was entranced by the detail in the guitars. Never before had the sound of the strings snapping off of Eric Clapton’s fingers been so clear. 
Aretha Franklin’s I Never Loved a Man the Way I Love You (Mobile Fidelity Sound Lab) is one of my favorite classic R&B CDs. This is an older album from 1967, with some obvious recording flaws. For this reason, I was surprised at the size of the stage that I was now getting. The separation between the instruments was now better than I would ever have expected. On Track Five, “Don’t Let Me Lose This Dream,” I had instruments well outside my speakers and the walls of my room started to disappear. There was almost no blending or smearing of instruments. On “Hells Bells,” the first track on AC/DC’s Back in Black CD (ATCO Records), the large bell in the intro rang beautifully and filled the room with sound. The guitar appeared clearly set back on the right side of the stage. When the kick drum and bass came up, the whole stage was set in front of me. I found the volume creeping up and staying up. I cannot typically listen at these levels for extended periods, but with the PI 4 installed, much of the harshness was removed and the detail exposed. 
I had a great time cycling through the Jazz Masters Volume Two set (Da Music) that I just picked up. Stephane Grappelli and Barney Kessel play “It Don’t Mean a Thing If It Ain’t Got That Swing” better than I have ever heard it before. Grappelli did things with his violin that I didn’t think were possible, and Kessel is no less amazing on guitar. The stage is set with Kessel on the left and Grappelli on the right. With this track, the walls in my room vanished and I was transported out of my listening room to the original event.AudioRevolution.com editor Bryan Southard and I have been friends for many years and we live relatively close to one another in Northern California. We have traveled far and auditioned many products together over the years. As Southard has reviewed most of the higher-profile A/C power products for Audiorevolution.com over the years, I felt it appropriate to bring the Transparent PowerIsolator 4 to his reference system for a second opinion and further testing. We made several direct comparisons to other A/C power units in his system and his opinion wholeheartedly echoed mine. It was his opinion that among all of the power products that he has reviewed, no other A/C product drew greater separation between the instruments and the surrounding air than the Transparent PI 4. I felt that he was initially skeptical about this product, because the word “filtering” had conjured up thoughts of poor filter-based products of the past. In direct comparison, Southard felt that the regeneration devices that he had reviewed in the past had done very positive things for the instruments themselves, but felt that they appeared to do little to the black areas between the instruments and rather fooled the ear into believing that these spaces were quiet. It was our opinion that the Transparent PI 4 had significantly better vocal and instrumental textures and provided a more relaxed and detailed presentation, allowing us to experience more of the physical event. It was Southard’s opinion that the PI 4 was the best A/C product that he had heard to date and one that he personally recommends at the highest level. Downside The Transparent PowerIsolator 4 is a tremendous value when compared to other power-related products. It performs exceptionally and will make “sheer” magic. However, at $1,895 each and with the potential need for more than one, this product is best suited for A/V systems that are already high performers seeking additional performance. Due to cost, I would only recommend the PI 4 for A/V systems costing $8,000 and up. Conclusion If you like the sound of your system now, wait until you hear how much better it can sound with cleaner power. For those skeptics out there, you don’t know what you have been missing. I was nothing short of amazed at how much of an improvement that the Transparent PowerIsolator 4 made in my system and Southard’s alike. I have some great equipment and had started to wonder if it could get much better. The PowerIsolator 4 has opened my mind to the possibilities. I can only imagine what would happen if I had all of Transparent’s power cords and four or five of the PI 4s. When I tell people how expensive my sound system is, some ask why I don’t just sell all of my equipment and spend the money going to live performances. All I can say to that is that a good music playback system can be like a time machine. How much would you pay to be transported back in time to your favorite musician’s best performance, and have the best seat in the house? The Transparent PowerIsolator 4 will take you that much closer to the live event. In the world of A/C optimization, it is unequaled at any cost. Transparent offers less expensive units for smaller system priced from $575. Music and movies used in review: Scooby-Doo (DVD) • Bob Belden - Shades of Blue (CD) • Eric Clapton - Unplugged (CD) • Aretha Franklin’s I Never Loved a Man the Way I Love You (CD) • AC/DC’s Back in Black (CD) • Jazz Masters Volume Two set (CD) |
|
Amplifier
• Classe CA-150 • Linn Klimax Twin • Aragon 2007 Preamp • Audio Research LS22 • Conrad Johnson Premier 18LS • Linn Klimax Kontrol Video Processor • Aragon Stage One • Classe SSP 30 MK II CD Transport • Theta Data Basic |
D to A converter
• Muse Model 2 with Bessel filter DVD player • Phillips DVD 751 Projection screen • Stewart Film Screens Firehawk 84” Speakers • Revel RF-30’s • Revel C30 center channel • Martin Logan Aerius • Klipsch- REF 7 Home Theater Speaker System |
Cables • Wire Wold Eclipse ll speaker cables and balanced interconnects • Nirvana digital cable • Kimber 8 TC rear and center speaker cables Accessories • ASC tube traps • Transparent Power Isolator IV |
|
Have you checked out the Transparent PowerIsolator 4? Tell the Revolution what you think about this review. Back to Transparent Cable. |
Contact Transparent at: Transparent Cable 47 Industrial Park Road Saco, ME 04072 USA Phone: (207) 284-1100 Fax: (207) 284-1101 Email: transparent@transparentcable.com Website: http://www.transparentcable.com |